Project Peer Reviews

Overview

For this assignment, you are to evaluate another group's project reports for both Project Part 1 and Project Part 2. This is an individual assignment, and you will be randomly assigned a report to evaluate the Monday after the report deadline. Team reports that you will need to evaluate will be posted on the Project page for you to access.

Deliverables

Evaluation for Part 1

You must upload an electronic copy (PDF) of your evaluation to Canvas. Your evaluation must cover the following portions of the report:

  • Introduction.
  • User Description.
  • Models
    • Sequence Model.
    • Artifact Model.
    • Flow Model.
    • Culture Model.
    • Physical Model.
  • Strengths and Limitations of Existing Practices.
  • Next Steps.

All evaluations must include an additional short discussion of the report's strengths and weaknesses and should be no more than a page long.

Evaluation for Part 2

As for Part 1, we will post team submissions on the web page. The pdf will contain what the team submitted: the vision, UED, overview, and low fidelity prototypes. The link to the video will be shown so that you can just go to it directly.

You must upload an electronic copy (PDF) of your evaluation to Canvas. Your evaluation must cover the following portions of the submission:

  • Vision.
  • Personas and their scenarios using storyboarding.
  • Written overview of the design:
    • Summary of users, specific goals, and problems with current practices.
    • Summary of proposed system.
  • Prototypes.
    • Wizard-Of-Oz video.

The evaluation should cover both the strengths and weaknesses of each portion of the submission, and should be about a page long.